»´ä¤H¤åõ¾Ç·|ºô¶¡@http://hksh.site
¡m¤H¤å¡n¤G¢Ý¢Ý¤»¦~¤Q¤ë²Ä¤@¤¥|´Á
¬}¹î»P»{ª¾ªºÃö«Y
³¯¤å²»(¨|¹F°Ó·~§Þ³N¾Ç°|Ý¥ô§U²z±Ð±Â)
¡@¡@ºKn¡G¥»¤å¥H¦¥§®Ú¡]Bernard Lonergan, 1904-1984¡^ªº»{ª¾²z½×¡]cognitional theory¡^¬°°Q½×¹ï¶H¡C¬°¦¥§®Ú¡A»{ª¾²z½×¬°°ò¦¡A¦Ó¨ä¥Lªº½×z«h¬°©µ¥Ó¡CY°ò¦²z½×?©T«h¨äª¾ÃѤj·H©l±o«Ø¥ß¡C±q®ø·¥±¨¥¡A³o±o¥H§K°£¬Û¹ï½×¡BÃhºÃ½×©Î¯À¾ë¹ê¦b½×ªº§ðÀ»¡F±q¿n·¥±¨¥¡A«h¥i¥H±Mª`©óµo®i»P½T»{¸gÅç¬ì¾Ç¡B¼Æ¾Ç¡B±`ÃѪº¦³®Ä©Ê¡C¦Ó¦b¨ä»{ª¾²z½×¤¤¡A¨ä½×ÃÒ»PªÖ©w»{ª¾µ²ºc¤¤¨ã¦³¤@»¤¾É¥»©Ê¡]heuristic nature¡^¤×Åã±o¯S¥X¦Ó²M´·¡A¥»¤åº¥ý±NµJÂI¶°¤¤©ó¦¹¤@½×ÃD¡A¤S¥Ñ©ó»{ª¾ªº»¤¾É©Ê»P¥t¤@¤HÃþ¤ß²z²{¶H--§Y¡u¬}¹î¡v¡]insight¡^¡A±K¤£¥i¤À¡A¬G¥»¤å¥ç¬ù²¤´yz¨ä·N¡C³Ì«á¡A¥»¤å¥H¶}®i³o¼Ëªº»{ª¾²z½×©Ò§tÄá¦b¥j¨å»P²Îp¬ì¾Ç¼h±ªº·N¸q§@µ²¡C
¡@¡@ÃöÁä¦r¡G¬}¹î¡B»{ª¾µ²ºc¡B»¤¾É©Êµ²ºc¡B¥j¨å¬ì¾Ç»P²Îp¬ì¾Ç¡B¨t²Î¹Lµ{»P«D¨t²Î¹Lµ{¡C
¡@¡@¤@¡B¬}¹îªº·NÄ
¡@¡@¦¥§®Ú«Y¤@C¿q·|¯«¤÷¡A¨ü¹L§¹¾ãªº°ò·þ©v±Ð¯«¾Ç»P¤hªLõ¾Çªº²[ªa[1]¡A¦ý¨ä³Ì«nªº²z½×»Pì³Ð©Ê©Ê«~«o¨Ã«D¦b¤@¶}©l´N¥H¯«¾Ç©Î§Î¤W¾Çªºµ§½Õ¼g´N¡A¦Ó¬O¤@¨ãÅé¡BÓ§Oªº¨Æ¨Ò¬°¥XµoÂI¡Aˤ£¬O»¡§Î¦Ó¤Wì²z¤£«n¡A¦Ó¬O¥L»{¬°¦b§Ú̦¨´N¤@¥»Åé½×«e¡Aº¥ý¥²¶·¥ý¬O¨ãÅ骺¦s¦b¡A¦]¦¹¦¥§®Ú©ú½T¦a«Å¥Ü¦b§Îºcª¾ÃѤ§«e¡A¥²¶·¥ý¬ã¨s»{ª¾ªº¹Lµ{¡A»{ª¾²z½×¬O°ò¦¦Ó¨ä¥Lªº½×»¡¬O¨äÂX®i[2]¡A¦¥§ªº¥ø¹ÏY®M¥Î®ü¼w®æªº»ºµü¡A¨º´N¬O¦b¤H¦bÂàÅܦ¨¦s¦³¾Ç¦¡¡]ontological¡^¤§«eº¥ý¥²¶·n¥ý¬O¹ê¦sªº¡]ontic¡^[3]¡A¦Ó±q¹ê»Ú¨Æ¨ÒªºÅé»{»·¤ñ°ª²`ªº²z½×¨Óªº©ö©ó²z¸Ñ¨Ã¥B«HªA[4]¡C
¡@¡@ªü°ò¦Ì¼w¡]Archimedes 287-212 B.C.¡^ªº¬ðµM¬}¹î¦è¤è«ä·Q¥v¤¤±`¬°¤H´£¤Î¡A¦¥§®Ú¤]¤£¨Ò¥~[5]¡F¦b¥t¤@¦a¤è¡A¦¥§®Ú«h¥Î¬f©Ô¹Ï¹ï¸Ü¿ý¡AĬ®æ©Ô©³ªº¤Þ¾É»P¤pªB¤Íªº¬}¹î¬°¨Ò[6]¡A¥Í°Ê´y¼g¬}¹îªº¹Lµ{¡F¦P¼Ëªº¡A¤û¹y¦bÄ«ªG¾ð¤Uªº¬}¹î¡A«h¦½«¬°¶Ç©_¡C³o¨Ç¬}¹îÆJµMµo¥Í¥B¤£¥i¹J´Á¡A¦Ó¨äµ²ªG«oÅý¤H±o¥H±q±´¨sªººò±i¤¤©ñÃP¡F¥t¤@¤è±¬}¹îªº®Ú·½¨Ó¦Û©óÓÅ餺¦bªº±ø¥ó¦Ó¤£¬O¥~¦b±ø¥ó¡A«oÅý¨ãÅ骺¨Æ¨ÒÂà¤Æ¡Bºëºé¦¨©â¶Hªºì²z©Îªk«h¡A¨Ã³Ì²×¦b¤ß´¼¤W¦¨¬°¿n²ß¡C[7]
¡@¡@³o¨Ç¬}¹î¥Ñ©ó¥t¤@ºØ¬}¹î--§Y¤Ï¦V¬}¹î¡]inverse insight¡^ªº³Q·N·|¦Ó³Q½á»Pª½ºI¬}¹î¡]direct insight¡^ªººÙ¿×¡C¦¥§®Ú»{¬°¡A¥¿¦V¬}¹î¤D¬O´x´¤¤F°ÝÃDªº«ÂI¡A©Î¬Ý¨ì¤F¸Ñµª¡B©Îµo²{¤F²z¥Ñ¡F¤Ï¦V¬}¹î«h¬O»â·|¨ì¦b¬Y¨Ç±¡§Î¤U¨ä«ÂI´N¬O¨S¦³«ÂI¡A©Î¨ä¸Ñµª®Ú¥»´N§_©w¤F¦³¸Ñµª³o¤@¦^¨Æ¡A¬Æ©Î¨ä¹D²z´N¬O¹ê¦bªº²z©Ê©Ó»{¤F¤Àª[»P«×ªº¦s¦b¡C[8]ȱoª`·Nªº¬O¡A¤Ï¦V¬}¹î¤]¬O¤@ºØ¬}¹î¡A¦Ó¤Á¤£¥i¥H¡u¥¢¹î¡v¡]oversight¡^²V¬°¤@½Í¡A¥¢¹î¬°¨S¦³§â´¤«ÂI¡A¦Ó¤Ï¦V¬}¹î«h¬O§â´¤¤F°ÝÃD¤§¨S¦³«ÂI¡C
¡@¡@¤Ï¦V¬}¹îªº¨Ò¤lÁöµM¤£¦h¡A¦ý·í·NÃѨì¬Y¤@°ÝÃD¥i¯à¬O¿ù»~ªº°ÝÃD®É¡A©¹©¹´N¬O¶i¨B³Ì¤j¤§®É¡C¤j½Ã¡E±Z¦è¡]David Tracy¡^´N½á»P¤Ï¦V¬}¹î--¦Ó¤£¬Oª½ºI¬}¹î¡A¬°¡uµø°ìÂಾ¹B°Ê¡v¡]horizon-shifts-movements¡^µo¥ÍªºÃöÁä[9]¡A±Z¦è©Ò¨¥¡uµø°ìÂಾ¡v·N¿×µÛ¤@ÓÆ[ÂIªº«¤jÅܾE¡C³oÓÂಾ¨Ã¤£ª½±µ¦a«ü¦V·sªº¤F¸Ñ¡A¦Ó¬O¹º¤U¤F·sªº°ÝÃD¬É½u¡A¦]¦¹¶}±Ò¤F¥þ·sªº¥i²z¸Ñ©Êµø°ì¡CÁ|¨Ò¨¥¡A¤û¹yÃhºÃ¥H©¹¦b¹ïª«Åé¹B°Ê¸ÑÄÀªº¥i²z¸Ñ©Ê¡A¦]¦¹«ÅºÙ¥H«eªº°ÝÃDÁ`¬O³ò¶¦b¦¹¤@«í±`³t«×±q¦ó¦Ó°_®Ú¥»¬O¿ù»~ªº´£°Ý¡A¦]¦Ó«P¨Ï¥LÂà¦V¤@Ó§ó¦X²z»P§ó¥i¯à¦³¦¨ªGªºª«Åé¥[³t©Ê°ÝÃD¤§¤W¡C¤û¹yªº²Ä¤@¹B°Ê©w«ß«ü¥X¤F¡u°ÊªÌ«í°Ê¡BÀRªÌ«íÀR¡v¡A§Y¦b©óªí©ú¡A¹B°Ê¤¤ªºª«Å饿¦pÀR¤îª«Åé¤@¼Ë¡A¨Ã¤£»Ýn¦³¤@±À°Êªºì¦]¡C[10]
¡@¡@¥t¤@¤è±¡A¤Ï¦V¬}¹î»P¤Õ®¦¡]Thomas Kuhn 1922-1996¡^©Ò«üºÙªº¡u¨å½dÂಾ¡v¡]paradigm shift¡^¦ü¥G¥ç¦³°Û©M¤§³B¡G¥Î¤Õ®¦ªº¸Ü¡A·í±`ºA¬ì¾Ç©Îª¾ÃѨå½dµo¥Í¸ÑÄÀ¤Wªº¿ù»~©Î©¼¦¹Å㤣¬Û®e®É¡A©ÎªÌ¨å½d©ÒµLªk¸ÑÄÀªº¥¼¹w´Á²{¶H«ùÄòµo¥Í¡A²×¨s±N·|»P¨ä¥L¨å½d²£¥Í«¤jªº¤£¬Û®e¡A«h¶Õ¥²²£¥Í¬ì¾Ç²©R¡A³o·N¨ý¤F±q®Ú¥»¤W§_¨M¤Fì¥ý°ÝÃDªº¦Xªk©Ê¡C¤Õ®¦»{¬°¨å½d»P¨å½d¤§¶¡ªº®t²§¬O¦p¦¹¹ý©³¡A¥HP±µ¨ü¤£¦P¨å½dªº¬ì¾Ç®a¤§¶¡¹ê»Ú¤W¬O³B©ó¤£¦Pªº¥@¬É¡A±q¦¹Æ[ÂI¨¥¡A¨È¨½´µ¦h¼wªº¥@¬É¤£©ó¤û¹yªº¥@¬É¡A¦Ó¤û¹yªº¥@¬É¤S¤£¦P©ó¶q¤l²z½×ªº¥@¬É¡A´«¨¥¤§¡A¨å½d»P¨å½d¤§¶¡¤£¥i¦@¶qªº¡]Incommensurable¡^¡C[11]´«¨¥¤§¡A³o¬O¤@ºØ¤Ï¦V¬}¹î¡C
¡@¡@¦Ü¦¹¡A§ÚÌ¥i¥H¬°³ò¶¦b¬}¹î¶gÃ䪺¦Wµü¤U¤@¬É©w¡A²¨¥¤§¡Aª½ºI¬}¹î»P¤Ï¦V¬}¹î¦PÄÝ©ó¦P¤@Ó¶¥¼h¡A§Y²z¸Ñ¡]understanding¡^ªº¼h¦¸¡F¤GªÌ¦P¼Ë«ü¦V¥i²z¸Ñ©Ê¡A¥¿¦V¬}¹îµo²{¥i²z¸Ñ©Ê¡A¤Ï¦V¬}¹îµo²{¥i²z¸Ñ©Êªº¯Ê¦p¡C³o¨Ç¥ç¥i³Q²ÎºÙ¤§¤º¬Ù²z¸Ñ¡]introspective understanding¡^¡A©Ò§â´¤ªº¬}¹î¦¥§®Ú¥ç²ÎºÙ¤§¬°¡u¤º¬Ù¬}¹î¡v¡]introspective insight¡^¡A°tÄÝ©ó®©©Ê¡]intelligence¡^¼h¦¸¡C·íµM¡A¦³¤F¤º¬Ù¬}¹î«á´N·|¤Þµo¶i¤@¨Bªº¤Ï¬Ù¡A§Y²£¥Í¤Ï¬Ù²z¸Ñ¡]reflective understanding¡^³o¤]¬O¤@ºØ¬}¹î¡C³o®É¹J¨ìªº°ÝÃD¬O§ñÃö¤Ï¬Ùªº°ÝÃD¡A[12]©Ò§Î¦¨ªº¬}¹î´NºÙ¤§¬°¤Ï¬Ù¬}¹î¡]reflective insight¡^¡A¤Ï¬Ù¬}¹î«h°tÄÝ©ó·NÃѪº²Ä¤TÓ¶¥¼h¡A«ü¦V§PÂ_¡C[13]
¡@¡@¤G¡B»{ª¾µ²ºc
¡@¡@¦b¼á²M¤F¦¥§®Ú¦³Ãö¡u¬}¹î¡v¤@µüªº¥Î»y¤ÀÃþ«á¡A§ÚÌ·|µo²{¡A¬}¹î¨Ã«D³æ¤@ªº¦æ¬°¡A¦Ó¬O¦b¾ãÓ»{ª¾¹Lµ{¤¤¡A§êºtµÛ®Ö¤ß¥B¼Ï¯Ãªº¨¤¦â¡G¦]¬°¬O¦p¦¹®Ö¤ß¡A¤HÌ¥i¥H²³æÁ`µ²¦¨¬°¤@¡u²z¸Ñªº¦æ°Ê¡v¡]an act of understanding¡^¡AÅý¤H̱qµLª¾¨ì¹FÁA®©¡F¦]¬°¬O»{ª¾¬¡°Êªº¼Ï¯Ã¡A¥¦Åý¤H±q²z¸Ñ¹L´ç¡B¬ï³z¨ì¤@¨ãÅ骺½×Â_¡C³o¼Ëªº¾ãÅé¹Lµ{¥iºÙ¤§¬°»{ª¾¬¡°Ê¡A¨ä°ò¥»ªºn¯À¥]¬A¤F±q¸gÅç±Â»P¡]empirical presentations¡^¡B±´°Ý¡]inquire¡^¡B¬}¹î¡]insight¡^¡B·§©À¤Æ¡]conception¡^¡B¤Ï¬Ù¡]reflection¡^¡B¤Ï¬Ù¬}¹î¡]reflective insight¡^¡A¥H¤Î³Ì«á²£¥Í§PÂ_¡]judgment¡^¡C
¡@¡@¦Ó³o¼Ëªº»{ª¾¹Lµ{¡A¦¥§®ÚÁ`¦X¦W¬°»{ª¾µ²ºc¡]cognitional structure¡^¡An¨¥¤§¡A«h¬°¸gÅç¡]experience¡^¡B²z¸Ñ¡]understanding¡^¡B§PÂ_¡]judgment¡^¡A³o¤@±ø¡u¤TªÑ¦X¤@¤§¯Á¡v¡]triple cord¡^[14]¦@¦Pºc¦¨»{ª¾ªº«ÈÆ[©Ê¡A¨ä¤¤¸gÅ窺²Õ¦¨¦¨¤À¥]¬A¤F¡AÅ¥¡Bµø¡B¹Á¡BIJ¡B»Dµ¥¥~¦b·P©x¡A¥H¤Î¦U¦¡¦U¼Ëªº·Q¹³¡B²Î¦X¡B°O¾Ðµ¥¤º¦b¸gÅç¡F²z¸Ñªº²Õ¦¨¦¨¥÷¬O»¡²z´¼±N¸gÅç©ÒÀò±oªº»P¥ó²Õ´¨ì¥i²z¸Ñªº¾ãÅ餧¤¤¡A¿ë§O»P¥ó¤¤ªº¥i²z¸Ñ©Ê¡A´£¥X¨Ã¦^µª¡u³o¬O¤°»ò¡v¡A¡u¬°¤°»ò·|¦p¦¹¡vµ¥°ÝÃD¡F³Ì«á¦³§PÂ_ªº¦¨¥÷¡A¨M©w¬O¨ä©Ò¬O¡A¦Ó«D¨ä©Ò«D¡C³o¼Ë¤@¨t¦Cªº¹Lµ{Ãþ¦ü¬YºØ¤º¦bªº¥l³ê¡]call¡^¾úµ{¡A¡u¸gÅç¥l³êÁA¸Ñ¡FÁA¸Ñ¥l³ê§PÂ_¡v¡A³Ì²×²z´¼«D±o§@¥XªÖ©w©Î§_©wªº¸Ñµª¡A¥H¹F¨ì¨Æ¹ê¨s³º¦p¦óªº¹Ò¬É¡A§_«h¤£·|²×¤î¡C
¡@¡@°µ¬°¤@¾ãÅ骺µ²ºc¨ä¦UÓ¾úµ{©¼¦¹»Ýn¨Ã¥B¼h¼h¬Û¦]¡C¨¥¨ä©¼¦¹»Ýn¤D¬O¦b©ó¡A¥H»{ª¾¹Lµ{¤£¬O³æ¤@·P©xªº¹B§@¡A¡]¦p¥u¦³¸gÅç¡A¨S¦³²z¸Ñ»P§PÂ_¡^¤]¤£¬O¬Y´XÓ·P©xªºÁp¦X¡A¤£¥i¯à¬O¾ã¥þªº»{ÃÑ¡C¶i¤@¨B¦a¡A¤]¤£¬O³æ¤@ªº»{ª¾¯à¤O©Î¬Y´XÓ»{ª¾¯à¤OªºÁp¦X¡Cµøı©ÎIJı©Î¥ô¦ó·P©x¦p¤£³sô²z¸Ñ´N¥u¬O¯Âºéªº¸gÅç¡A¾ã¥þªº»{ÃѦ³¿à¦UºØ©x¯à¶¡¦@¦Pªº¦X§@¡F²z¸Ñ¬¡°ÊYµL¸gÅç§@¥Î¥çµL¥i¯à¡F¦P¼Ë¦a¡A²z¸Ñ¤´»Ý§PÂ_§@¬°¯u°²¹ï¿ùªº¼Ð·Ç¡C¦]¦¹»{ª¾¬¡°Ê¥Ã»·»Ýn¾ãÅ骺°t¦X¡A»{ª¾ªºµ²ªG¡]§PÂ_¡^¤]³\·|¿ù¡A¦ý¨º¥¿¬O²£¥Í¶i¤@¨B°ÝÃD»P¬}¹îªºì¦]¡C
¡@¡@¥t¤@¤è±¡A»{ª¾¾úµ{ªº¼h¼h¬Û¦]¤D¬O¦b©ó¡A¥¦§ó¯à¤Þ¾É§A±q¤@Ó¼h¦¸¬ÛÄ~¦aÂà¤Æ¨ì¥t¤@Ó¼h¦¸¡Aª½¨ì³Ì«áªº¶¥¬q¹F¨ì¡A§Y§PÂ_¤~ºâ§¹¦¨¡C¨änÂI¬O¡G²Ä¤@¼h¦¸ªº¥]¬A¤º¦bªº»P¥~¦bªº·P©Ê¸gÅ礣¬O»{ª¾ªº¥þ³¡¡A¦Ó¬O»{ª¾ªº¤@³¡¤À¡F¦P¼Ë¦a¡A²Ä¤G¼h¦¸ªº®©©Ê¤]¥u¬O»{ª¾ªº¤@³¡¤À¡A¥u¦³¨ì²Ä¤TÓ¼h¦¸¢w¢w§Y§PÂ_¡A¤~¯àºâ§¹¦¨»{ª¾ªº¹Lµ{¡C·í¤@Ó¤H°µ¤F§PÂ_¡A¨º·N¨ýµÛ±µ¯Ç¤F©Ò¦³¤TÓ¹Lµ{¡A¾ã¦X¨ìºÙ¤§¬°»{ª¾¬¡°Êªº³æ¤@µ²ºc¤§¤¤¡C[15]
¡@¡@³Ì«á¡A§Ṳ́]¥²¶··NÃѨì¡A¸gÅç¡B²z¸Ñ¡B§PÂ_ºc¦¨ªº»{ª¾µ²ºc´N¨ä¥»¨¨¥¬OªÅ¬}ªº¡]empty¡^[16]¡A¬O¤£Ó¯A¤Î¤º®eªº§Î¦¡¡]form¡^¡A¸gÅç¡B²z¸Ñ»P§PÂ_ªº¬¡°Ê¦³«Ý¨ãÅ骺¡BÓ§OªºÓÅé¥h¹ê½î¡B¥hº¡¥þ¡A¦Ó§ÚÌ¥¿¬O¦b³o¼Ëªº¹ê½î¤¤Åé»{¨ì¡]appropriate¡^¦³³o¼Ëªº§Î¦¡»Pµ²ºc¦s¦b¡C¬°¦¹¦¥§®Ú¤£¥u¤@¦¸´£¨ì¡m¬}¹î¡n³o¥»®Ñ¥i¥H´yz¬°³o¼Ë¦Û§ÚÅé»{ªº¤@¨t¦C½m²ß[17]¡A¥L»¡¡G
¡@¡@º¥ý¡A¦Û§ÚÅé»{¬O¤@ºØ´£¤Î¡A´£¤Î¦Û¤v¥¿¦b¸gÅç¡B²z¸Ñ©M§PÂ_¡A¨ä¦¸¡A¬O¤@ºØ²z¸Ñ¡A²z¸Ñ¦Û¤v¥¿¦b¸gÅç¡B²z¸Ñ©M§PÂ_¡F²Ä¤T¡A¬O¤@ºØªÖ©w¡AªÖ©w¦Û¤v¥¿¦b¸gÅç¡B²z¸Ñ©M§PÂ_¡A¨ä«á¹ïª¾ÃѪº¤ÀªR¡A³Ì²×«ü¦V¤F³o¤TÓ¤¸¯À¡A§Y¸gÅç¡B²z¸Ñ¡B§PÂ_¡C[18]
¡@¡@¥¿¦]¬°»{ª¾µ²ºc¥»¨¬OªÅ¬}ªº¡A¹ï¥¼ª¾ªº¨Æª«´N¥²¶·¹ê»Ú¥h¸gÅç¡B²z¸Ñ»P§PÂ_¡A¤HÃþ«ç¼Ë¥h±´¯Á¥¼ª¾¡B±o¨ì¸Ñµªªº¨ãÅé¾úµ{´N¬O§ÚÌ¥H¤Un°Ýªº¡A¬°¦¹¡A¦¥§®Ú§Y´£¥X³o¼Ë¤@Ó»¤¾É©Êªº¤èªk¡]heuristic method¡^¡C
¡@¡@¤T¡B»¤¾É©Ê¤èªk
¡@¡@»{ª¾ªº»¤¾É©Ê¤èªk¬O¦¥§®Ú«ä·Q«Ü¯S§Oªº³¡¤À¡A±q«ez´XÓ¬}¹îªº¨Æ¨Ò¤¤¡A§Ṳ́w¥i¬ù²¤¬Ý¥X¬YºØ³q¹L¦Û§Ú±Òµo»P¦Û§Ú»¤¾É¦Ó§ä¥X¯u¬Û©Î¨Æ¹êªº¹Lµ{¡C±q»{ª¾ªºÅ޿趶§Ç¨Ó»¡¡A¬}¹î°µ¬°¤@µ²ªG¡A¦Ó¦Ûµo©Êªº¦Û§Ú»¤¾É«h¥¿¬O¬}¹îªºì¦]¡C¤Wzªº¨Ò¤l¤¤§Ú̬ݥX¤F¤H̹良ª¾ªº´÷¨D¡A´÷±æª¾¹Dªº¤ß´N¬O¦Û§Ú»¤¾É¥h¨Dª¾ªº°Ê¤O¡C¬G»¤¾É©Ê»P¨Dª¾¤èªk¤§¶¡¨ã¦³¬Û·íÃþ¦ü¤§µ²ºc¡A¦Ó§ó«ê·í¦a»¡¡A¦Û§Úªº±Òµo©Î»¤¾É´N¬O¤HÃþÀò±o¯uª¾ªº¤èªk¡A¦p¦P»{ª¾µ²ºc¤£¥i³æ¿W¦¨¥ß¡A¦P¼Ëªº¡A¦Û§Ú»¤¾É»P¨Dª¾¤èªk¤D¬O¤@Å骺¡CÁ`¤§¡Aª¾ÃѪº³e³q©Ê¡]coherence¡^¥i¿×¦¥§®Úª¾Ãѽתº¯S¼x¡C¦¥§®Ú¨¥¡G
¡@¡@¤@Ó¤èªk³Qµø¬°¨ã¦³»¤¾É©Ê¬O°ò©ó³o¼Ëªº·N¸q¤U»¡ªº¡G¥¦¯à¨ó§U§A¥hµo²{§AÁÙ¤£ª¾¹Dªº¡C³oÓ°ò¥»ªº»¤¾É©Ê´N¬O¦b½Í¨ºÓ«ü¾É§A´Â¦V¬}¹îªº°ÝÃD¡AÂǵÛÂà¤Æ¤º¥~ªº·P©Ê¸gÅç¨ì¥¼¨Ó¥i¥H»â®©ªº¸gÅç¤W¡A§Y»{ª¾¨ì¥¼ª¾ªÌ±N¥i¥H¬°§Ú©Òª¾¡C[19]
¡@¡@»¤¾Éªº¤èªk±q¥H¤U¨âÓ¨Ò¤l¥i¥H¬Ý±o«Ü²M·¡¡G¤@¡B¡u¥N¼Æ¡v¡]algebra¡^ªºÆ[©À¦¦b¬ì¾Ç²©R¥H«e´N³Q±µ¨ü»P¹B¥Î¡A¤H̱N¥¼ª¾ªÌ©R¦W¬°x¡A¨Ì¾Ú¤wª¾ªÌ»Pxªº¬Û¤¬Ãö«Yºc§@¤@¤èµ{¦¡¡A¦Ó³q¥Î¼Æ¾Çªº¹Bºâ¡A¨D¥XxªºÈ¡A¤]´N§ÚÌnªº¥¿½Tµª®×¡C¨ä¦¸¡A¦b¤HÃþ¾ú¥v¤¤§ÚÌÁ`¬O¤£Â_¦a¦b±´°Q½Ñ¦p¥Í©Rªº¥»©Ê¡]the nature of life¡^¡B¤õªº¥»©Ê¡B¯à¶qªº¥»©Êµ¥µ¥¡A¬Æ¦Ü¦b®Ú¥»ÁÙ¤£ª¾¹D¥L̪º½T¤Á¥»©Ê¤§«e¡A´N·|¥h°Q½×¡B¨¥»¡»Pª§½×¨ä¥»©Ê¡A¦b³oºØ±¡ªp¤U¡A§ÚÌn°Ýªº¬O¡A¬°¤°»ò¤H·|¥h°Ý¤@ª«ªº¡u¥»©Ê¡v¡H¨ä¨s³º¦³¦ó·NÄ¡H·í§ÚÌ»¡¥Í©Rªº¥»©Ê®É¡A¨º´N·N¿×¥Í©R¬°§ÚÁA¸Ñ®Éªº¼ËºA¡A¦]¦¹³oÓ¥»©ÊªºÆ[©À´N¬O¨ºÓÅý±´¨s´Â¦Vªº¼Ðªº¡C
¡@¡@¦b¥N¼Æ¤¤§Ú̹B¥Îx¡A¦Ó¦b¤@¯ë¨¥½Í¤¤¡A§Ų́ϥάYª«ªº¥»©ÊªºÆ[©À¡A¬Yª«ªº¥»©Ê´N¬O¨º¨Ç§ÚÌn¤£¤wª¾n¤£¥¼ª¾¤§ª«ªº¦WºÙ¡A©Ò¥H·í¤H°Ý¤@ª«¬O¡u¤°»ò¡H¡v®É¡A§óºë½Tªº»¡¨º´N¬O¦b°Ý¤@ª«¨ä¥¼ª¾ªº¡u¥»©Ê¬O¤°»ò¡H¡v¡C[20]·í§Ú̸߰ݥN¼Æx©Î¬Yª«¤§¥»©Ê®É¡A¥L̦@¦P¨ã³Æ¤@¯S½è¡A§Y¥L̳£¥NªíµÛ¥¼ª¾ªÌ¡CµM«hÁöµM¥¼ª¾¡A«o¥i¥Hµ¹©w¤@Ó¦WºÙ¡A¦nÅý§ÚÌ¥i¥H§ä¥X¸Ñµª¡C¦ý¤@Ó®Ú¥»°ÝÃD¡G§Ú̦p¦ó¦bÁÙ¤£ª¾¹D§ÚÌ·|¹F¨ì¤°»ò¥Ø¼Ð¡A´N¦³©Ò¿×ªº»{ª¾ªº°Ê§@¥i¨¥©O¡H³oªº½T¬OÓÃøÃD¡A¬°¸Ñ¨M³oÓÃøÃD¡A°£«DªÖ©w§Ṳ́w©Î¦h©Î¤Ö¡uª¾¹D¡v¨ºÓ¥¼ª¾ªÌ¬O¤°»ò¡C
¡@¡@³oÓ¹ï¸Ñ¶}°ÝÃDªº¥ýÅç¡]a priori¡^·NÃÑ¡A¥Î¦¥§®Úªº¥Î»y¬°¡u¥i³Q»{ª¾ªº¥¼ª¾¡v¡]known unknown¡^¡C[21]¦Ó¹ï³oÓÃøÃDªº¦^µª´N¬O»¤¾É©Êªºµ²ºc¡A§Y¹ï¥¼ª¾°_Ó¦W¦r¡A§ä¥X¥L̪º¯S©Ê¡A¹B¥Î³o¨Ç¯S©Ê©w¦V¡B©w§Ç¡B«ü¾É¨ä±´°Ý[22]¡A³oÓ¥i³Q»{ª¾ªº¥¼ª¾´N¬O¤HÃþ»¤¾É©Êµ²ºcªº¥²n«e´£¡A¤]¬O»¤¾É©ÊÆ[©Àªº²Ä¤@Ó¨BÆJ¡C
¡@¡@·í§Ú̸Ѷ}x¡A¤]´N¬O¸Ñ¶}xªº¥»©Ê¡A¨ºªí¥Ü§Ú̹ï¤@ª«¦³¤F¬}¹î¡A¤@ª«©Ò¾Ö¦³ªº¥»©Ê¬O´¶¹Mªº¡B¬Û¦Pªºª«¡A¨äÄÝ©Ê¡Bªí¼x¥ç·|¬Û¦P¡A¨º´Nªí¥Ü§ÚÌ¥i¥H¥Î¬Û¦Pªº¼Ò¦¡¨Ó²z¸Ñ¥LÌ¡A³o§Y¬O¡u¬Û¦Pª«¥H¬Û¦P¤è¦¡ªºÁA¸Ñ¡v¡]The similars are similarly understanding¡^[23]ì«h¡A³oÓì«h¬O»¤¾É©Êªº²Ä¤G¨B¡A³oÓì«h«D±`¦³¥Î¡A¦ý«o¤]¥²¶·ÄYÂԨϥΡC
¡@¡@¤@¤è±¡A¦b³oÓì«h¤§¤U¡A¬Û¦Pªº±´¨s©Î¹êÅç¥i¥H¤£¥Î«ÂЦa§@¡A¦]¬°¦pªG¤@ª«¦b¨C¤@Ó¼h±§¡»P«e¶µª«¬Û¦P¡A§Ṳ́£¥i¯à¹w´Á¹ï¥L̦³¤£¦P¥H©¹ªº¬}¹î¡]·íµM³o¬On¦b¨ä¬}¹î¬O¥¿½Tªº«e´£¤U¡^¡C¦p·í§ÚÌn¬ã¨s®ñ¤À¤l®É¡A§ÚÌ¥u»Ý¤@Ó®ñ¤À¤l¡A¦ÓµL»Ý¶°¦X©Ò¦³®ñ¤À¤l¡A¨º¦b¨Æ¹ê¤W¤]°µ¤£¨ì¡C¥t¤@¤è±¡A³oÓì«h¥²¶·³QÂÔ·V¦Ó©wªº¹B¥Î¡A¦]¬°¦b¦¹©ÒÁ¿ªº¡u¬Û¦P¡v¤£¬O¦b¥~ªí¬Ý°_¨Ó¬Û¦P¡A¤£¬O¥ô¦ó¦b¥i·P»P¥ó¤W¡B¥~§Î¤W¡BÃC¦â¤W¡B·Pı¤W¡BÅ¥°_¨Ó¤W¬Û¦P¡A¶Ç²Î¤¤°êªº«ä·Q¡BÂåÀø©Î·¤ôµ¥¡A±`·|±N¤HÅ骺Ŧ¾¹©Î®a©~ª¬ªp»P¦ÛµMªº¡B¥~¦bªº¹êª«¬Û³sô²z¸Ñ¡A¥H¥i·Pªº¬Û¦ü©Ê°µ¬°¬Û¦ü²z¸Ñªº®Ú·½¡A´Nµ´«D³o¸Ì©Ò«üªº¬Û¦Pª«¥i¥H³Q¬Û¦PªºÁA¸Ñ¡A³o¸Ì©Ò«üªº¬Û¦Pª«¬O«ü¤@ª«¦b¬Û¦P±ø¥ó¤U¡B¦b¦P®É¡B¦b¦P¼Ëªº¼Ð·Ç¤U¦³¬Û¦PªºÅܤƵ¥µ¥¡CY³oºØ±¡ªp¤U¡A¦pªG§Ų́D¥X¤@¤½¦¡¡A§ÚÌ¥i¥H±N¤§¹B¥Î¡B¸ÑÄÀ¬Û¦Pªº±¡ªp¡C
¡@¡@«eªÌªº¬Û¦P©Ê¥Î¦¥§®Úªº¸Ü´N¬O¡uª«»P§Ú¬ÛÃö¡v(correlation of thing to us)ªº¬Û¦P©Ê¡A¦Ó«áªÌ¬O¡uª«»Pª«¬ÛÃö¡v(correlation of one to another)ªº¬Û¦P©Ê[24]¡A«eªÌªº§P·Ç¬°·P©x¡]sense¡^¦Ó«áªÌªº§P·Ç¬°´ú¶q¡]measurement¡^¡C¥¿¬O«áªÌµ´¹ï©Ê¦a«Pµo¤F¼Æ¾Ç»P¬ì¾Çªº¶i¨B»Pµo®i¡C¥¿¦p¦¥§®Ú«ü¥X¡G
¡@¡@Æ[¹îÅý¸ôµ¹´ú¶q¡A´ú¶qÃö«YµÛ¦¹ª«»P¥Lª«¦Ó¤£¬O»P§Ú̪º·P©x¡F¦Ó¥B¶È¶È¬O¦b¤@Ó§ó¥[ºë·Lªºª«»P¥Lª«ªºÃö«Y¤U¡A³y´N¤F¸gÅ窺¥æ¤¬§@¥Î¡B¨ç¼Æ©Î©w«ß¡C²{¦b²M·¡ªº¬O¡A¦pªG©w«ß¬O¦b®ø°£¤FÆ[¹îªÌªºª«»P§Ú¤§¶¡ªºÃö«Y¡A¦Ó¬O¥H¦¹ª«»P¥Lª«ªº´ú¶qÃö«Yªº±¡ªp¤U¹F¨ìªº¡A¨º»ò´N¯àªÖ©w¨ºÓì«h©Îªk«h¨ã¦³¤@Ó«D±`éTªº°ò¦¡A¹ï©Ò¦³ªºÆ[¹îªÌ³£¬O¬Û¦Pªº¡A¦]¬°¥L̳æ¯Â¦a©M§¹¥þ¦a¥~¦b©óÆ[¹î¬¡°Ê¡CÁ|¨Ò¦Ó¨¥¡A¥~Å㪺¤£¬OÃC¦â¦Ó¬O¥Î¥úªºªiªø¤§»y·J¤U¦Ó±o¨ìªº´¶¹M¸ÑÄÀ¡A¨º¬O¤£½×¨ºÓÆ[¹îªÌ²´·ú³B©ó«ç¼Ëªºª¬ºA¡B¥L̦b¬Ý®Éªº¥ú½u¡B©ÎªÌ¦b¬Û¹ï¹B°Ê¤¤¥i¯à²£¥Íªº³t«×µ¥µ¥¡A¨äµ²ªG¬Ò¬O§¹¥þ¬Û¦Pªº¡C[25]
¡@¡@«e¬ì¾Ç®É´Á»P¬ì¾Ç²©R«á¡A»{ª¾ªº»¤¾É©Ê¦b²Ä¤@¨BÆJ¬O¤@Pªº¡A³£¬OªÖ©wª«ªº¬Y¨Ç¥¼ª¾¥»©Ê¡A¦Ó¦¹¥»©Ê¥i¥H¬°§Ú©Òª¾¡A¦ý¦b²Ä¤G¨BÆJ«o¬O¨Ï¤§¦b¹ï¨Æª«ªº²z¸Ñ¤W§eÅãºIµM¤£¦Pªº¼Ë»ª¡C
¡@¡@Á|¨Ò¦Ó¨¥¡A¬°¨È¨½´µ¦h¼w©Î¨ä¥L¦´Áªºõ¾Ç®a¡A¤õ³Qµø¬°¤@ºØ¤¸¯À¡]element¡^¡A¦ý·í¥Nªº¤Æ¾Ç®a«hµø¤õªº¿U¿N¬°¤@ºØ®ñ¤Æ«¬ºA¡C¦P¼Ëªº¡A¦÷§Q²¤¤§«eªº¬ì¾Ç®a«h±NÂ\¡]¦pÄÁÂ\¡^µø¬°¤@Ó¨ü¨ì§í¨îªº¤U¸¨ª«Åé¡A¥¦²×±N³vº¥¹F¨ìÀR¤îª¬ºA¡Aª½¨ì¦÷§Q²¤¤~ªì¨ã¡uºD©Ê¡vªº·§©À¡A¬Y¤@¹B°Ê¤¤¤§ª«Åé¡A¦b¤@©w±ø¥ó¤U±N«ÂгoºØÂ\°Ê¡C¨Ì¦¥§®Úªº¨£¸Ñ¡A«eªÌ¬O¤@ºØª«§ÚÃö«Yªº¡u´yz¡v¡A¦Ó«áªÌ«h¬°ª«ª«Ãö«Yªº¡u¸ÑÄÀ¡v¡AµM«h¹ïª«ªº¡uÆ[¹î¡v¤è¦¡·|¤£·|§ïÅܪ«ªº¥»©Ê¡H³oÓ«n°ÝÃD±qªñ¥N¥H¨Ó´N»P¡uªì©Êvs.¦¸©Ê¡v¡B¡u²{¶Hvs.ª«¦Û¨¡v°ÝÃD²o§è¤£²M[26]¡C
¡@¡@²{¦b¡A§Ú̦]¦¹¥²¶·¤p¤ß°Ï¿ëª«ªº¡u¥»©Ê¡v·§©À©M¸ÑÄÀªº·§©À¡C¹ê«h²{¥N¤HÆ[¹î¨ìªº¤õ»P¨È¨½´µ¦h®É¥Nªº¤õ¨ÃµL¤£¦P¡AY¦]¸ÑÄÀªº¤£¦P¦Ó§_©w¨È¨½´µ¦h¼w©Ò¨£¤§¤õ¡A¨º¥½µL²§¬O»¡¤GªÌ¤£¬O¤@¨Æ¡AY¤GªÌ¤£¬O¤@¨Æ¡A¨º¥½Yn¨¥»¡¥LÌ¥u¬O¸ÑÄÀ¤£¦P¤]·|¬O¿ùªº¡A§Y¤GªÌY¨S¦³¬Û¦P¥»½è¡A¦p¤ô»P¤õ¤§¤£¦P¡A«hn¥Î§¹¥þ¤£¦PªºÆ[ÂIÆ[¹î¡A¦Ó¤£¬Oª«»P§Ú©Îª«ª«¤§¶¡ªº°Ï§O¡C[27]¦P¼Ëªº¡A¤@§â°íµwªº¡Bºî¦âªº¡BºÝ¥¿¥¿¦a¦b§A±«e®à¤l¡A»P¥Ñì¤l¦¨¡B¤£¯à«äijªº²Ó¤pª«½è¡BµL¦â¥B¥H¤£¥iµø¦a°ª³t²¾°Ê®à¤l¡C¥L̨㦳¬Û¦Pªº¥»©Ê¡A¥u¬O¦]¬°¸ÑÄÀªº¤£¨¤«×¤£¦P¡A¦Ó¦³¤£¦P²z½×¡C[28]
¡@¡@¦b¦¥§®Ú³Ì«nªº¯«¾Ç§@«~¡m¯«¾Ç¤èªk¡n¤¤¡A¥L±N¼Æ¾Ç»P¬ì¾Çµo®iªºµ²ªG¡A©w¦ì¬°¤HÃþ»{ª¾ªº¡u¨t²Î»Ý¨D¡v¡]systematic exigency¡^[29]¡A·N«ü¦¹®É¤H̤w¸g¤£º¡¨¬©ó¥u¬O´yz©Êªº»{ª¾¡A¦Ón¨D±Nª¾ÃѨt²Î¤Æ¡A§ó·Ç½T¦a»{ÃÑ¡B©w¸q¨Æª«¡A¦]¦ÓÂà¦Ó¨Ï¥Î¤@¨Ç¬ì¾Ç¤èªk¡A±Nª`·N¤OÂಾ¨ì¨Æª«ªº¤º¦bÄÝ©Ê¡C
¡@¡@·íµM¡A¥²¶·ÁA¸Ñ¤£¬O»¡´yz©Êªº»{ª¾µ´µM¤£¨ã¨t²Î©Ê¡A¦ý©úÅ㪺¬O´yzªº»{ª¾Ãö¯A¨ìªº¬O¤H»P¤HªºÃö«Y¡BÀô¹Ò¡BªÀ·|µ¥¡A§ÚÌÁA¸Ñ¥L̤£¬O³q¹L¬ì¾Ç¤èªk¡A¦Ó¬OÂǵ۾DZo©ÎÂȬVªº¦Û§Úq¥¿ªº¹Lµ{¡AÅý¨ä¬}¹î±o¥H³vº¥ªº²Ö¿n¡BÁpµ²¡B©w©M¦J¥¿¿ù»~¡C¬ì¾Çªº»¤¾É©Ê¤èªk«h±Ä¥Î¤F§ó¦hªº²z½×»y¨¥¡]theoretical language¡^¡A¦p¡u½è¶q¡v¡]mass¡^¡B¡u·Å«× ¡v¡]temperature¡^µ¥»y·J¡G¬ì¾Ç®a©Ò¿×ªº½è¶q«üªº¤£¬O«¶q¤]¤£¬O¦ì¸m¡F¦ÓÁöµMª÷ÄÝ·Pı°_¨Ó¤ñ¤ìÀY§ó§N¡A¦ý¥LÌ¥i¯à¦³¬Û¦P·Å«×¡A¬ì¾Ç´N¬O³oºØ¥æ¤¬Ãö«Y¤U«Ø¥ß°_¬Y¨Ç²z½×¡C·§¨¥¤§¡A¼Æ¾Ç»P¬ì¾Çªº¦Û§Ú±´°Ý¥¿¬O±Nª¾ÃѨt²Î¤Æªº¨å«¬¡C
¡@¡@µM¦Ó¡A³oºØ¤HÃþ»{ª¾ªº¡u¨t²Î»Ý¨D¡v¥²¶·n¦b¤@©w±ø¥ó¤U¤~¯à¦¨¥ßªº[30]¡A¬ì¾Çªºªk«h©Îì²z¯à°÷¾A¥Î¨ì¨ãÅ骺±¡ªp¤´¥²¶·º¡¨¬¤@¨Ç±ø¥ó¡A¨ãÅé¦Ó¨¥¦³¡G
¡@¡@¤@¡B¥²¶·¹ï¨ãÅ骺±¡¹Ò¦³¥R¤Àªº¸ê°T¡F¤G¬O¥²¶·n¹ï¨ä¬ÛÀ³ªºªk«h¦³¥R¤Àªº»{ÃÑ¡F³Ì«á¤]¬O³Ì«nªº¬O¡A¹B¥Îªk«hªº¬ì¾ÇÁÙ¬O»Ýn¹ï¨ä±¡¹Ò¦³¨ä¬}¹î[31]¡C
¡@¡@¦bº¡¨¬¤F³o¨Ç±ø¥ó¤§«á¡A¬ì¾Ç®a¤~¦³¯à¤O¹ï¹ê»Úªº¨Æ¨Ò°µ¥X±ÀÂ_¡]inference¡^¡A³o¤S¥i¤À¬°¨âºØÃþ«¬¡G
¡@¡@²Ä¤@ºØºÙ¤§¬°¹ê»Úªº½×Â_¡]practical inference¡^¡A³o¬OÄÝ©ó¾Ö¦³¹ê»Ú©Ê®æªº¤Hªº¤§¤ß²z¡A¥L̲ߺD©óµ¥«Ý¨ãÅ骺±¡ªpµo¥Í¡A¨Ã¥H¬Û¹ïÀ³ªº¬}¹î¸Ñ¨M°ÝÃD¡A¦Ó¤£¸ÕµÛ¥h¦ôp¥¼¨Ó¡B¹w·Q¥i¯àµ²ªG¡C¥¿¦]¬°¹ïÀ³ªº¬}¹î¥u¾A¥Î©w¹ïÀ³©w«ß¡A¦]¦¹§½©w«ßÀ³¥Î¨ì¥L³Bªº¥i¯à©Ê¡A¬GµLªkºtö¶g¸Ôªº¨t²Î²z½×¡C¦ýÁÙ¦³¥t¥~¤@Ãþ¤H¡A¦¥§®Ú¤]ºÙ¤§¬°¡u²z½×ªº¤ßÆF¡v¡]theoretical mind¡^¥LÌ´N·|¥h¹w·Q¤@Ó²z·Qªº¡]ideal¡^©Î¨å«¬¡]typical¡^ªº¨Ò¤l¡A¤£³Q§ô¿£¦b¬J»Pªº±¡¹Ò¡A¦Ó¬O¹ï¥¼¨Ó¥i¥Hµo²{ªº©w«ß¦Û¥Ñªº¡B¥J²Óªº±´¯Á¡A±q¤¤«õ±¸¥X¥L̪º¡u°ò¥»±¡ªp¡v¡]basic situation¡^[32]¡A¨Ã¥h¨M©w¦b¨CӮרҤ¤·|¦p¦óºtÅÜ¡C¦]¦¹³o¼Ëªº¬}¹î¬O´I¦³³Ð³y¤O»P«Ø³]©Êªº¡C
¡@¡@¦¥§®Ú»{¬°¡A¥j¨åªº¬ì¾Ç®a¥i¥H§@¥X¹w´Á©Êªº½×Â_¡A´N·N¨ýµÛ³o¨Ç²z·Qªº©Î¨å«¬ªº¹Lµ{¬O¥i¥H¦a¦b¬ÛÀ³ªº¨ãÅ鱡ªp¤¤³Q¡uÅçÃÒ¡v¡]verified¡^¡A¦P®É¾É¤Þ¤TÓ«D±`ȱoª`·Nªºµ²ªG¡A¤À§O¬O¡G ²Ä¤@¡B¬Y¨Ç¬}¹î©Î¤@¨Ç¨t¦Cªº¬}¹î¤£¥u¥i¥H§â´¤¾ãÅ骺¹Lµ{¡AÁÙ¥i¥H§â´¤¦b¾ãÅ餤ªº¨CӨƥó¡C²Ä¤G¡B³oÓ³æ¤@¬}¹î©Î³æ¤@¶°¦Xªº¬}¹î¡A¯à°÷ªí¹F¬°¤@Ó¬Û¤¬¹ïÀ³¦Ó³sµ²¦¨¦³®Äªºªk«h©Î©w«ß®É¡A¨º»ò´N¥i¥H³Qºtö¨ì¨ä¥Lªº±¡ªp¡A¦Ó§¹¥þ¤£¥Î¦Ò¼{¨ä¥Lªº¤zÂZ±¡ªp¡C²Ä¤T¡B·í¤HÌ©|¥¼±oª¾¨äªk«h©Î©w«ß®É¡A¦ý³o¨Ç²z·Qªº©Î¨å«¬ªº¹Lµ{ªº½T¦s¦b¡A¥L̪º¬ã¨s´N¨É¦³¤F¤@©w¼Æ¶qªºÓ§OÀu¶Õ¡C[33]
¡@¡@³o¨ÇÓ§OªºÀu¶Õ´N¬O¦b¾ãÅé¹Lµ{¤¤±o¨ì¤@Ó¡u¥i²z¸Ñªº¾ã¤@¡v¡]intelligible unity¡A©ÎĶ¡u¥i²z¸Ñªº²Î¤@Åé¡v¡^¡C[34]§ó¶i¤@¨B¨¥¡A§â´¤¥i²z¸Ñªº¾ã¤@©Ê´N¬O¦bÓ¹Lµ{§â´¤¤F¤TºØÀu¶Õ¡G
¡@¡@¤@¡B¥ô¤@±¡¹Ò¤¤ªº¸ê®Æ©Ò®i¥Üªº·N¸q¡A»P¾ãÓ¹Lµ{ªº¸ê®Æ¨ã¦³¬Ûµ¥·N¸q¡C¤G¡B¦pªG¸ê®Æ¦b¥ô¤@±¡ªp¤U³Qµo²{¨ã¦³²`¸q¡A¨º»ò¬ÛÃþ¦üªº¸ê®Æ¦b¥ô¦ó¤@Ó¨ä¥L±¡ªp¦P¼Ë¨ã¦³²`¸q¡C¤T¡B¥ô¤@±¡ªp©Ò§e²{ªº³ø§i¤§¥¿½T©Ê¡A¥i¥H¾Ú¥HÀˬd¨ä¥L±¡ªpªº³ø§i¡A¤¬¬Ûªº¦LÃÒ¡A¿Å¶q©¼¦¹ªº·Ç½T«×¡C[35]
¡@¡@¥j¨å¬ì¾Çªº±´¨s¸g¾ú¤F³o¨Ç±´¯Á¹Lµ{¡A¥Î¦¥§®Úªº¸Ü¡G·í««ªº¤º¦b§xÃø³Q§JªA¦Ó¤@¥¹¹F¨ì°ò¥»¬}¹î®É¡]basic insight¡^¡A³o®É±´¨s´N¹Gªñ¤F¤@Ó²×·¥®É¤À¡]supreme moment¡^¡A³o®É©Ò¦³ªº¸ê®Æ«K·|¬ðµM¦a±Æ¦C¦¨¡u³æ¤@Æ[ÂI¡v¡]single perspective¡^¡A³o¨Ï±o¥þ±¡u®u±²¡v¡]sweeping¡^¥H©¹¸gÅç¡A¨Ã¨Ï¥¿½TªººtöÅܱo¥i¯à¡A¦ÓÀH¤§¦Ó¨Óªº·Ç½T¹w´ú±N·|ÃÒ©ú¥ý«eªº¬}¹î¬O·Ç½Tªº¡C[36]
¡@¡@µM¦Ó¡A¥j¨å¬ì¾Ç±N¥@¬Éµø¬°¤@Ó¾ãÅé¦Ó½Õ¬d¬ã¨s¡A¸Õ¹Ïµo²{©ñ½Ñ¥|®ü¦Ó¬Ò·Çªº©w«ß¡A¦ý³oÓ¥@¬É²¦³º¦³µÛ¤Ó¦hªº¡u¥©¦X¡v¡]coincidence¡^¥i¯à¦P®Éµo¥Í¡A¥H¦Ü¬ì¾Ç®a¤£¥i¯à§¹¥þ¦Ò¼{¥þ³¡¨Æ¥ó¡C³o¶Õ¥²¨Ï¥j¨å¬ì¾Ç®a¤@¤è±©â¥X¡u¥i²z¸Ñ¡vªº³¡¤À¡A¥t¤@¤è±¤]¥²¶·©Ó»{¬Y¤@³¡¤ÀµLªk¡u¤@µ·¤£ÎA¡v¡B¡u¤À¬í¤£®t¡vªº¬ã¨s¡A³o¯u¬O¤@ºØ¹ï¡u²z¸Ñ©Ê¡vªº«µû¦ô»P«©w¸q¡C²¨¥¤§¡A©Ó»{¥j¨å¬ì¾Çªº¦³©Ê¡A¥¿¬O«ezªº¤Ï¦V¬}¹îªº¦n¨Ò¤l[37]¡C³oºØ¬}¹î«P¦¨¤F¤H̤£¿WÁé©ó¥j¨å¬ì¾Ç¡A¦ÓÂà¦V¥t¤@ºØ²z¸Ñªº¼Ò¦¡¡A¤]´N¬O²Îp¬ì¾Ç¡C
¡@¡@²Îp¬ì¾Ç¦¨¥ßªº²z¥Ñ¬O©Ó»{¬Y¨Ç³¡¤ÀµLªk³Q¨t²Îªº¬ã¨s¡A¥Ñ¦¹¦¥§®Ú«·s¤Ï¬Ù¤F¥@¬Éªº¡u¹Lµ{¡v¡]process¡^¡C¥L»{¬°¡A³oÓ¥@¬Éªººc¦¨¥i¥H³QÂk¯Ç¬°¨âÓ¡u¹Lµ{¡v¡A¤@¬O¥i¥H³Q¦³¨t²Î¦a¡B¦³²Õ´¦a¡]systematically¡^¹ï«Ý¡A¦Ó¨ä¹Lµ{¥i¥H³Q¤@өΤ@²Õ¬ÛÃö¬}¹î©Ò§â´¤¡A¥iºÙ¤§¬°¡u¨t²Î¹Lµ{¡v¡]systematic process¡^¡C¥t¤@¤è±¡A«h¬OµLªk¥H¨t²Î©Êªº²´¥ú¨Ó³B²zªº¡A¨ä¹Lµ{µLªk³Q²ÎÄá¦b¤@өΤ@²Õ¬ÛÃö¬}¹î¡A§Ú̹ï¥LÌ¥u¯à¦³¡u³¡¤Àªº¡v¡B¡u¹s¬Pªº¡v¬}¹î¡C´NºÙ¤§¬°ªº¡u«D¨t²Î¹Lµ{¡v¡]non-systematic process¡^¡C
¡@¡@¨t²Î¹Lµ{´N¬O¥Î¨Ó«ü¯A¥j¨å¬ì¾Ç©Ò¬ã¨sªº¹ï¶H¡C¦p«e©Òz¡A¨t²Î¹Lµ{¬O«üY¤@Ó¹Lµ{¤£¨ü¹Ò¥~¤zÂZ¡A«h¤@±¡¹Ò¤¤ªº¸ê®Æ©Ò®i¥Üªº·N¸q¡A¦b¾ãÅé¹Lµ{¤¤´N³Qµø¬°¦³·N¸q¡C¦Ó¦b¤@±¡ªp©Ò¾É¥Xªº³ø§i¡A¥i¥H¾Ú¥HÀˬd¡B¦LÃÒ¡A¿Å¶q©¼¦¹ªº·Ç½T«×¡C¦b¥j¨å¬ì¾Çªº±´¨s¤¤¡A¬ì¾Ç®a¾ú¸gÆ[¹î¡B±À²z¡B¹êÅç¦Ó¤@¥¹¹F¨ì°ò¥»¬}¹î®É¡A±q¨º¤@¨è¶}©l©Ò¦³ªº¸ê®Æ§Ï©»¬ðµMÅܱo¡u¨ã¦³²z©Ê¡v¡A¬ì¾Ç®a±o¥H¹ï²{¶H°µ¥X¸ÑÄÀ¡A¦Ó¨Ï¥¿½TªººtöÅܱo¥i¯à¡A¦Ó¨ä¹w´úªº¥¿½T©Ê¤]±NÃÒ©ú¨ä¬}¹î»P©w«ß¬O¥¿½Tªº¡C
¡@¡@»P¨t²Î¹Lµ{¹ï¤ñ¡A«D¨t²Î¹Lµ{¤@µü«h¦b©ó´yz¨º¨ÇµLªk§ä¥X¤@²Õ¬Û³s³eªº©w«ß¡A¨Ó¸ÑÄÀÓ§O±¡ªpªº¾úµ{¡C¦b³oºØ¹Lµ{¤¤¡A¬ã¨sªÌ¥u¯à¨Ì¿àÓ§O¬}¹î¥H¤Î©Ò¹ïÀ³ªº©w«ß¡A¨Ó§â´¤¾ãÅé¹Lµ{ªºÓ§O³¡¤À¡A³o¨ÇÓ§O¬}¹îªº²Õ¦X¨Ã¤£¯àºc¦¨¡u¥i²z¸Ñªº¾ã¤@¡v¡C³o¬O¦]¬°¨Æ¶µªº²Õ¦¨¨Ã¤£¨ã¦³¨t²Î©Ê¡A¦¥§®Ú¨Ï¥Î¡u¥©¦X¶°¦¨¡v¡]coincidental aggregates¡^³oÓ³N»y¨Óªí¥Ü³oºØ¡uÂ÷´²¡v¡B¡u¹s¬P¡vªº²Õ¦¨¡C
¡@¡@¨ãÅé¦Ó¨¥¡A¨t²Î¹Lµ{»P«D¨t²Î¹Lµ{³ÌÂA©úªº¹ï¤ñ¡A¥i¥H±q¡u¬PÅé¹B°Ê¡v»P¡u¤Ñ®ðÅܤơv¤GªÌ¤Ä°Ç¥X¨Ó¡C¹ï²{¥Nªº¤Ñ¤å¾Ç®a¦Ó¨¥¡A¦³¦Û«Hªº´yz»P¹w´ú¹L¥h©Î¥¼¨Ó´XÓ¥@¬öªº¤é»k©Î¤ë»k¡A¬O¥i¥H·Ç½T¹F¨ìªº¡F¦ý¹ï®ð¶H¹w³øû¦Ó¨¥¡A·í¥L̹w³ø©ú¤Ñªº¤Ñ®ð®É¡A«h»Ýn¤@Ó§Y®Éªº»P§ó·sªº¸ê°T¡A¤~¯à§@¥X¦³«×ªº¹w´ú¡C¦Q¸Þªº¬O¡A§Ú̽T«H¦a¹w´ú¥¼¨Ó´X¦Ê¦~ªº¤Ñ¶H¡A«oµLªk§¹¥þ´x´¤©ú¤Ñªº¤Ñ®ð¡A¨ä²z¥Ñ¦ó¦b¡H
¡@¡@¤£ºÞÄ@¤£Ä@·N¡A§Ú̳£¥²¶·¦P·N¡A«eªÌªº¤Ñ¶H¬O¬YºØ«ÂЩʰªªº¦Ó¦b¥»½è¤W¦³°ª«×¤@P©Êªº¹Lµ{¡A¬Û¹ïªº¨ã¦³¤@ӲΤ@ªº¥i²z¸Ñ©Ê¡A©ÎªÌ¥Î¿Õ¨©º¸ª«²z¾Ç±o¥DÁ§¤B®æ¡]Erwin Schr?dinger 1887-1961¡^ªº¸Ü¬O¡u±q¦³§Ç²£¥Í¦³§Ç¡v¡]order-from-order¡^[38]¡C«áªÌªº¤Ñ®ð«h¥²¶·Æ[¹î¥i¯àÀH®ÉºtÅܪº±¡ªp¡A·í³oºØ±¡ªp²£¥Í¼@¯PªºÅܤƮɡA·sªº¬}¹î´NÅܱo¦³¥²n¡A³o·N¨ýµÛ¤Ñ®ðÅܤƨS¦³²Î¤@ªº¥i²z¸Ñ©Ê¡C´«¨¥¤§¡A¬O¤@ÓµL¨t²Îªº¹Lµ{¡C
¡@¡@±¹ïµL¨t²Î¥@¬Éªº¦s¦b¡A¦¥§®Ú»{¬°¥u¦³³z¹L²Îp¬ì¾Çªº¤èªk¤~¥i¥H¹F¨ì¡]Á§¤B®æºÙ²Îp«¬ªº¾÷¨î¬°¡u±qµL§Ç²£¥Í¦³§Ç¡vorder-from-disorder¡^[39]¡C§ó«nªº¬O¡A³oÓ²z¸Ñªº¤èªkÁÙ¬O®Ú·½©ó¥DÅéµ²ºc¡A¦¥§®Ú´NºÙ¤§¬°¡u²Îpªº»¤¾É©Êµ²ºc¡v¡C³Ì¦nªº¼á²MÁÙ¬O³q¹L¹ï¤ñ¡A¸Û¦p¦¥§®Ú©Òz¡G
¡@¡@¥j¨åªº»¤¾É©Êµ²ºc¬O¤@Ó¨t²Î»P©â¶Hªº²z¸Ñ©Ê¹w´Á¡A¦b¨ºùس\¦h¨ãÅ鱡ªpÁͦV¤@P¡C²Îpªº»¤¾É©Êµ²ºc¤]¬O¤@Ó¨t²Î©M©â¶Hªº²z¸Ñ©Ê¹w´Á¡A¦ý³]©w¤F¤@Ó½d³ò©M¼Ð·Ç¡A±q¨º¸Ì¶}©l¡A³o¨Ç¨ãÅé¨Æª«¤£¯à¬O¨t²Î¦a¤À®í¡C[40]
¡@¡@ÅãµM¦a¡A¥j¨å©M²Îpªº»¤¾É©Êµ²ºc¬O¬Ò¬O¤HÌ¥ø¹Ï²z¸Ñ¥@¬Éªº¤èªk¡C¬Û¹ïªº¡A¥j¨å¬ì¾Ç©M²Îp¬ì¾Ç´N¬O¦¹¤@²z¸Ñªº¨ãÅ馨ªG¡C¤GªÌ¤¬¬°ªí¸Ì¡B¬Û»²¬Û¦¨¡C¥H¬ì¾Ç®aªº¦¨´N¨Ó¤Ï±À¨ä¨Dª¾ªº³~®|¡A´N¯à¬Ýªº§ó¬°²M·¡¡G¬°¥j¨å¬ì¾Ç©Ò¬ã¨sªº¡A¤D¬O¹ï§Y±Nµo¥Íªº±¡ªp¦³µÛ¦p¨ä©Ò¬Oªº¹w´Á¡A³oºØ½T©w©Êªº¹w´Á¬O¦b¡u¨ä¥L±¡ªp¤£ÅÜ¡v«e´£¤§¤U¤~¥i¯à¹ê²{ªº¡C¦ý²Îp¾Ç®aªº¬ã¨s«h¤j²§¨ä½ì¡A¥LÌ©ÒÃö¤ßªº«hª½±µ»P½Ñ¨Æ¥óªº¡u¥©¦X¶°¦¨¡v¡]coincidental aggregates¡^¢w¢w§Y½Ñ¥©¦Xºc¦¨ªº¾ãÅé¢w¢w¦³Ãö¡C
¡@¡@¥©¦X¶°¦¨ºc§@ªº¥i²z¸Ñ©Ê¥i¥Ñ¡u¾÷²v¡v¡]probability¡^³oÓÆ[©À§@¥X¾A¤Áªí¹F¡A«ê¦p?ÂY¤@ªT¿ú¹ô¥i¯à¥X²{¥¿¤Ï¨â±¡A¥á¤@Ó»ë¤l¦³¤»ºØÂI¼Æ¥X²{ªº¥i¯à©Ê¡C¿ú¹ô¥X²{¥¿¤Ï¨â±ªº¾÷²v¦U¬°¤G¤À¤§¤@¡A¦ý»ë¤l¥X²{¥ô¦ó¤@±ªº¾÷²v«h¬°¤»¤À¤§¤@¡C¦b³o¸Ì¦³¤@Ó¦³½ìªº¹ï·Ó¡A¨º´N¬O¿ú¹ô©Î»ë¤l¨C¤@¦¸ªº¸¨¤U³£¥i¥HÅçÃÒ¥j¨å«ßªº¡u¹ï½T©Ê¡v¡]validity¡^¡]¦÷§Q²¤¤]¥i¥H¦b?ÂY¿ú¹ô®Éµo²{©ÎÅçÃҦۥѸ¨Åé©w«ß¡^¡A¦ýÅãµM²Îp¾Ç®aÃö¤ßªº¨Ã¤£¬O¥j¨å«ß¡A¥LÌ©Ò´Á±æÀò±oªº¬O¥t¥~¤@ºØ¬}¹î«¬ºA¡C¦Ó¦b²{¹ê¥Í¬¡¤¤¡A¤×¥HÂå¥Í¤§¨Æ·~¯S§O¯àÆ[¹î¨ì¥j¨å©w«ß»P²Îp©w«ßªºª[²§¡C³o¥i¥H±q¨â¤è±¨¥¡A¤@¤è±Âå¥Íªº°V½mÅý¥L̯ॿ½T¦a¶EÂ_¬Y¯e¯fªºP¦ºì¦]¡]¥j¨å©w«ß¡^¡A¥t¤@¤è±¡A³o¨ÇÓ§Oªºì¦]¡A»P¶EÂ_¬Y¯fªº¦º¤`²v¡]²Îp©w«ß¡^¬O¨â¦^¨Æ¡C·íµMÂå¥Í¥²¶·¦P®É¾Ö¦³¨â¤è±ªºª¾ÃÑ¡]¥j¨å«ß»P²Îp«ßªº°t¦X¡^¡AÅý¥L±o¥H°µ¥X³Ì¾A©yªº§PÂ_¡AµM¦Ó¤@Ó¤GªÌªº¬Éªº²M·¡°Ï¿ë¤´¬OµL¤ñ«n¡C
¡@¡@²Îp¬ã¨s¤¤³Ì®Ö¤ß»P³Ì«n¤¸¯À¤§¤@¡A´N¬O¬Y¨Ç¹ê»Úµo¥Í¤§¦¸¼Æªº§ïÅܳQµø¬°µLÃöºòn¡A§YºÙ¤§¬°²Îp³Ñ¾l¡]statistical residue¡^¡C¦b?ÂY¿ú¹ôªº¨Ò¤l¤¤¡A§Ṳ́j·§¥i¥Hª¾¹DY?ÂY¿ú¹ôªº¦¸¼Æ°÷¦h¡A¨ä¥¿±´Â¤W»P¤Ï±´Â¤Wªº¥§¡¼ÆÀ³·íÁÍ©ó¤@P¡A¬YÓ¤H©Î¬Y®É¡A¤@©wµ{«×ªº®t²§¨Ã¤£ºR·´¥§¡¼Æ¡C³o¨Ç¯S®íªº¡BÓ§Oªº®t²§³QºÙ¤§¬°¡uÀH¾÷ªº®t²§¡v¡]random differences¡^¦Ó±µªñ¥§¡¼Æªþªñªº¦¸¼Æ¤~·|³Qµø¬°¦³·N¸q¡A³o¨Ç´N¥s°µ¡u¦³²`·N®t²§¡v¡]significant differences¡^¡C
¡@¡@ÀH¾÷ªº®t²§¦pªG°÷¦hªº¸Üªº½T¥i¯à¾ÉP¥§¡¼ÆªºÂ\°Ê¡A¦ý§ÚÌ·|µo²{¦pªG?ÂYªº°÷¦h¡A¨º¨Ç²`·Nªº®t²§¡A«o±`±`·|¸¨¦b¥§¡¼Æªþªñ¡A¦]¦¹ÀH¾÷ªº®t²§±`³Q©¿²¤¡C²Îp¬ì¾Ç®a»EµJ©ó²`·N®t²§©Ò¤Þ»âªº¡u²z·Q¤Wªº¾÷²v¡v¡]ideal probability¡^¥»¨´N¬O¤@ºØ¬}¹î¡A§ó«nªº¬Oı¹î¡uÀH¾÷®t²§¬O¥i¥H³Q©¿²¤¡vªº³o¤@¥ó¨Æ¤]¦P¼Ë¬O¤@ºØ¬}¹î¡C
¡@¡@ µM¦Ó¡A¦pªGÀH¾÷ªº®t²§¦û¹L¦h¤ñ¨Ò®É¡A§ÚÌ´N¥²¶·¦^¹LÀYÀ˵ø¨ä²z¥Ñ¡A·Q¹³¤@¤U¡A¨Ò¦pY?ÂY¿ú¹ô¦Ê¦¸¡A¬Ò¥X²{¦P¤@±¡A¨º»ò¹CÀ¸ªÌ©Î³\´N»Ýn¦³¤@Ó·sªº¡u¬}¹î¡v[41]¡C©Î¦p°Ò¥§º¸¡]Hugo Meynell¡^ªº¦³½ìĵ»y¡G¡uY¬Y¦a¨C¦Ê¤Hªº¦º¤`²v°ª©ó¾ãÓ°ê®aªº¦º¤`²v¦³´XÓ¤ë¡A¨º»ò´Nªí¥Ü·|¦³¤@¨Ç¦MÀIªºì¦]À³ª`·N¤@¤U¡A¦ý¦pªG³o¼Ëªº±¡ªpºû«ù´X¦~¡A¨º»ò´N»Ýn«Ü¦hªº¸ÑÄÀ¤F¡C¡v[42]
¡@¡@¬°¤°»ò·|¥H¡u²z·Q¤Wªº¾÷²v¡v°µ¬°¦³²`·Nªº¥Nªí¬O¤@Ó¦n°ÝÃD¡A¦^µª³oÓ°ÝÃD§ÚÌÁÙ¬O¥²¶·¦^¨ì¡u¥i²z¸Ñ©Ê¡v¡]intelligibility¡^³oÓÆ[©À¨Ó±´°Q¡C¨º´N¬O¡A§Ú̪º²z©Ê¬}¹î¨ì¦b²³¦hªº¥©¦X¶°¦¨¤¤¡A¥i¥H¾ã¦X¥X¦³¤@¨Ç¥i²z¸Ñ©Êªº¡B¦³¡uºD©Ê³W«ß¡v¡]regularity¡^ªº³¡¤À¡A¤ÀªR¥LÌ¥i¥H±o¥X¤@«í±`¤À¼Æ¡]constant proper fraction¡^¡A³oÓ«í±`¤À¼ÆÅܦ¨§Ú̲z¸Ñ»PÅçÃÒªº¥Nªí¡C¦b?ÂY¿ú¹ôªº¨Ò¤l¤¤¡A§ÚÌ«Ü®e©ö´N§â´¤¨ì¡B¬}¹î¨ì¨ä²z·Q©ÎµM²v¬°50%¡A¦ý¦b¥X¥Í²v©Î¦º¤`²vªº¨Ò¤l¤¤¡A²Îp¾Ç®a«h»Ýn§ó¦hªº¬ã¨s¡B²Îp¡B¤ñ¸û¡A¦Ó¯à¦b³Ì±o¥X²z·Q©ÎµM²v¡A°µ¬°¤ÀªR¡Bµû¶q»PÅçÃÒªº¼Ð·Ç¡C
¡@¡@ Y¥H¡u©â·Ï·|¾ÉPªÍÀù¡v³o¤@Âå¾Ç¤Wªº¡u¦@ÃÑ¡v¬°¨Ò¡A¹ê«hµL½×§^¤H°µ¹L¦h¤Ö¹êÅç¥R¨ä¶q¥u¯à¦bÄY®æ±±¨îªºÀô¹Ò¤U¹F¨ì¤@¯ë©Êªº¶É¦V¡A¦ÓµLªk±o¥X¡u¥²µM¾ÉP¡vªºµ²½×¡C¨º´Nªí¥Ü§ÚÌ¥²¶·º¡¨¬©ó¬Y¨Ç¡u¾÷²v¡v¡A«nªº¬O¦¹¤@¡u¾÷²v¡v¨Ã¥¼¦]¥uÄÝ»\µM¦ÓÅã±o¤£ºë½T¡C¬Û¤Ïªº¡A§^¤H¨ÌµM¥i±q¨ä¼Ë¥»¡]samples¡^¤¤±o¥X¬}¹î¡A·í¬Y¨ÇÀW²v¥X²{¯S§O°ª®É¡A¨ä¼Ë¥»´N¨ä¦³¥Nªí©Ê¦Ó¬°¥Nªí¼Ë¥»¡]representative sample¡^¡A¦Ó¦P¼Ë¸g¹L§^¤H©â¶H§@¥Î¥H«á¡A´N¥i¹ï¥¼¨Ó§@¥X¹w´ú¡C´«¨¥¤§¡AÁa¨Ï¤@ª«¦Û¨ªºÅܤƳQ©¿²¤¡A¦ý´N¾ãÅé¦Ó¨¥¤´¨ã¦³¥i²z¸Ñ©Ê¡C·íµM¡A¦b³oÓ¹Lµ{¤¤¡A¬}¹îªº¾A®É¥X²{ÁÙ¬O§êºt¤F«nªº¨¤¦â¡C¦pªG§Ṳ́w¸g§ãnªº®Þ²z¤F²Îp¬ì¾Çªº¯S¼x¡A±µ¤U¨Ó¡A§ÚÌ¥i¥H³z¹L¥j¨å©M©M²Îp±´¨sªº¤Ï¬Ù¡AÂç²M¤GªÌªºÃö«Y¥H¤Î¬}¹îªº®Ö¤ß¨¤¦â¡C
¡@¡@¥|¡B¹ï¥j¨å»P²Îp¬ì¾ÇªºÃþ¤ñ
¡@¡@º¥ý¡A¦pªG»P«e¬ì¾Çªº´yz©Ê»y¨¥¡]§Yª«»P§Ú¬ÛÃöªº±´¨s¼Ò¦¡¡^¬ÛÃþ¤ñ¡A¥j¨å¬ì¾Ç¬O±´°Q¬Yª«[x]ªº¥»©Ê¡]the nature of x¡^¡A²Îp¬ì¾Ç«h¬O±´°Q¬Y¨Æ¥ó[y]ªºª¬ºA¡]the state of y¡^¡FY¥j¨å±´¨s¥]¬A¤F´N¬On¸g¥Ñ¤£¦PºØÃþªº¸ê®Æ¤F¸Ñ¨ä¥»©Êªº¸Ü¡A²Îpªº±´°Q´N¬On¸g¥Ñ¤F¸Ñ¡u´¶³qªº¡v©M¡u¨Ò¥~ªº¡v¡F¡u¥¿±`ªº¡v©M¡u¤Ï±`ªº¡v¨Æ¥ó¹B§@¡A¶i¦Ó¤F¸Ñ¨äª¬ºA¡C¨Ã¥B¦b¡u¤Z¬Û¦Pªº´N¥H¦Pªº¤è¦¡¨Ó²z¸Ñ¡v³o¼Ëªº»¤¾É©w²z¡A³z¹L·P©x¡A±N¨ä¤Àªù§OÃþ´M¨D²z¸Ñ¡A¥H¨D»â·|¨º¨Ç¤w¸g¦s¦bªº¦ýÁÙ¨S¦³³QÁA¸Ñ³¡¤À¡C
¡@¡@¨ä¦¸¡A¤£ºÞ¬O¥j¨å©M²Îpªº±´¨s¡AY§ó¶i¤@¨Bªº²z¸Ñ«h»ÝnÂà¤Æ´yz©Ê»y¨¥¬°¬ì¾Ç©Êªº¸ÑÄÀ¡]§Yª«»Pª«¬ÛÃöªº±´¨s¼Ò¦¡¡^¡A¥j¨åªº±´¨s±q¨ãÅ骺´ú¶q¤¤¡A±N¼Æ¾ÚÂà¤Æ¬°¥i²z¸Ñªº¹Ïªí¡A¨Ã¾ã²z¦¨¦³§Çªº¨ç¼ÆÃö«Y¡C¦Ó²Îpªº±´¨s«h¬O±q¹ê»Úµo¥Íªº¦¸¼Æ¤¤¡A§ä¥X¨º¨Ç¨ã¦³¥Nªí©Êªº¦¸¼Æ¡A¾ã²z¦¨¥i¥H¾Ú¥H¤ñ¸û¡BÅçÃÒªº¡u²z·Q¤W¾÷²v¡v¤§¹Ïªí¡C°£¦¹¤§¥~¡A¤GªÌ¤]³£»Ýn¬ì¾Ç®a³z¹L¸gÅç¡B²z¸Ñ¡B§PÂ_ªº¾úµ{¡A«õ±¸¥X¦³·N¸qªº¬}¹î¡C¦]¦¹¥i¿×¬O¤@¦³«Ø³]©Êªº´¼©ÊÅD¤É¡]a leap of constructive intelligence¡^¡C
¡@¡@ ²Ä¤T¡B¥j¨å»P²Îp¬ì¾Ç¬Ò¬O´¶¹M»P©â¶Hªº¡Cº¥ý´N´¶¹M©Ê³o¤@ÂI¨¥¡G¥j¨å¬ì¾Ç©Ò´ú¶qªº¨Æª«¬OÓ§Oªº¡A¦ý±o¥Xªº©w«ß«o¬O´¶¹Mªº¡F²Îp¬ì¾Ç©Ò²Îp¨ìªº¬Û¹ï¹ê»Ú¦¸¼Æ¬OÓ§Oªº¡A¦ý©Ò¬}¹î¨ìªº¾÷²v¤]¬O´¶¹Mªº¡C¥¿¦]¬°©w«ß»P¾÷²v¬Ò¬°¦PÃþ¨Æª«©Ò¦@¦³¡A¦]¦¹¥i¥HÀ³¥Î¦b¦PÃþ¨Æª«¤§¤W¡C
¡@¡@ ³Ì«á¡A´N¨ä¹Lµ{¬O¤@ºØ©â¶H¨¥¡G¥j¨å©w«ß¤D¬O±qÓ§Oª«ªº¥©¦X¶°¦¨¤¤©â¶H¥X¬Y¤@¥»©Ê¡A¦b¥j¨å¬ì¾Çªº±´¨s¤¤¡A¹ïÆ[¹î¨ìªº²{¶H¤§®t²§»PÅܤƤQ¤Àªº«µø¡C¥j¨å¬ì¾Çªºµø¨¤±N¥@¬Éµø¬°¤@Ó¦³¨t²Îªº¥@¬É¡A¥i¥H³Q¦³¨t²Îªº²z¸Ñ¡A¦b³oÓ«e´£¤U¡A©Ò¦³ªº¸ê®Æ¬ÒÀ³·í³Q±´¨s¡B³Q¤ÀªR¡A¥H¨D¨äì²z¡Bªk«h¡C¤Ñ¤å¾Ç®a¦bÆ[¹î¦æ¬P¹B¦æ®É¡A¤£·|±N¬Y¨Ç¦æ¬Pªº¹C²¾µø¬°¯ÂºéµL³W«hªº¨Æ¶µ¦Ó©¿²¤¤§¡A¦pªG¬O³o¼Ëªº¸Ü¡A¨º»ò¦æ¬P¨t²Î¤£¥i¯à³Qµo²{¡C¦P¼Ëªº¡AµJº¸¡]Joule 1818-1889¡^¬O§_´¿¸gµLµø©ó²Ó¤pªºÅܤơAY¦p¦¹¡A¨º»ò¦³Ãö¹q¯à»P¼öÂà¤Æªº¾÷±ñµ¥¦¡´NÁÙ¨Sµo²{[43]¡CÁ`¦Ó¨¥¤§¡A³o¬O¦b¡u¨ä¥Lª«¤£ÅÜ¡v¡]other things being equal¡^ªºn¨D¤U¤~¥i¥H¹ê²{¡A³o®É¥©¦X¶°¦¨¤@·§³Qµø¬°¸gÅç³Ñ¾l¡C¦ý²Îp¾Ç®a¦b¥©¦X¶°¦¨¤¤¦A¤@¦¸µo²{¬YÓ¤º¦b¥i²z¸Ñ©Ê¡C±qÀH¾÷ªºª[²§¤¤±q¬ÛÃöªº¹ê»Úªº¦¸¼Æ¤¤©â¶H¬ã¨s¡A§Y©â¥XÀH¾÷ªº®t²§»P¦³²`·Nªº®t¶Z¡A¨Ã±q¤¤§ä¥X¤@ºD©Ê©Î³W«ß¡Aªí¹F¬°©ÎµM²v¡C
¡@¡@ ³Ì«á¡A¤£ºÞ¬O¥j¨å©Î²Îp¬ì¾Çªº¹ê¦b©Êªº½T¬Òn³q¹LÀËÅç¡A¦ý¥Ñ©ó¥Ḻ¹ïªº¹ï¶H¤£¦P¡A¦]¦¹¦³µÛ¤£¦PªºÅçÃҤ覡¡C¤jÅé¦Ó¨¥¡A¥j¨å«ß¬O»¡¦pªG¦b¨ä±ø¥ó³Qº¡¨¬ªº±¡ªp¤U¨ä¨Æ¹ê´N·|µo¥Í¡A¦Ó²Îp«ß¬O¤HÌ¥i¥H¹w´Á¨º¼Ëªº±ø¥ó¥i¥H¦hÀWÁcªº³Qº¡¨¬¡C¦AªÌ³o¤GºØ«¬ºA©M¤èªkªº¹w´ú®Ä¤O¤]©¼¦¹¤£¦P¡A¤jÅé¦Ó¨¥¡A¥j¨åªº¹w´ú¥i¥H¦b¤@©w«×¤º«O«ù¥¿½T¡A¦ý²Îpªº¹w´ú«h¦³¨ä«×¡C
¡@¡@¤¡Bµ²»y
¡@¡@¬}¹î¥»¬O¤@Ó¦³½ìªº¤ß²z²{¶H¡A¤H±`¸g¾ú³o¼Ëªº¹Lµ{¡A«o¤£¨£±o±`±`¹ï¦¹¨ã¦³·NÃÑ¡A¦ýµø¨ä¬°²z©Ò·íµM¨Ã¤£§tĨ䤣´¿¦s¦bªº·N¨ý¡C¥»¤å»{¬°¡A¤£ºÞ¬O¦b¬ì¾Çµo®iªº¾úµ{¤¤¡A¦bõ¾Ç®a±Òµo¥L̦ۤwªºÁA¸Ñ¤W¡A¬}¹îªº¦s¦b¬Ò¤£¥i©¿µø¡CµM¦Ó¡A¬O¤°»ò¼Ëªº¯à¤O«P¨Ï¬}¹îªº²£¥Í¡H¥»¤å¶¶µÛ¦¥§®Úªº¸}¨B±´°Q¤F¥DÅé±Òµo¦Û¤v¡B»¤¾É¦Û§Ú¡A³Ì²×µo²{¸Ñµªªºµ²ºc¡A³oÓµ²ºc¦b®Ú¥»¤W¡u´Ó°ò¡v©ó¸gÅç¡B²z¸Ñ¡B§PÂ_³o¤TÓÀôÀô¬Û¦©ªº¹B§@¶¥¬q¡C§Ṳ́]µo²{¡A¯S§O¦b¬ì¾Çµo®i¶iµ{¤¤¡A¤H̱ĥΤF¡uª«ª«¬ÛÃö¡vªº²z¸Ñ¼Ò¦¡¡A¥¿¬OÅýºë½Tªº¬}¹î§ó¬°¹üÅ㪺ì¦]¡C
¡@¡@¥t¥»¤å¤]¦P·N¦¥§®Ú¤HÃþ¦s¦b¥@¬É¦P®É¨ã³Æ¡u¨t²Î¹Lµ{¡v»P¡uµL¨t²Î¹Lµ{¡v¬Û¹ïªº¡A¥DÅé¹ï³o¨âºØ¹Lµ{ªº¬ã¨sϥͥX¨âºØ²z¸Ñ¼Ò¦¡¡A§Y¥j¨åªº»¤¾É©Êµ²ºc»P²Îpªº»¤¾É©Êµ²ºc¡A³o¨âºØ¼Ò¦¡¬Û»²¬Û¦¨¡A¦@¦Pºc¦¨¤HÃþªº¡u¬}¹î¤§ºô¡v¡B¡u²z¸Ñ¤§ºô¡v¡C
°Ñ¦ÒµÛ§@
¤@¡B¦¥§®Ú§@«~
Lonergan, Bernard J. F. Insight: A Study of Human Understanding, ¡]London:
Longmans, Green & Co., 1957; London: Longman & Todd, reprinted, 1958.¡^
¢w¢w¢w¢w, Collection, Edited by Frederick E. Crowe, ¡]New York: herder and
herder, 1967.¡^
¢w¢w¢w¢w, Method in Theology,¡]New York: Herder and Herder, 1972.¡^
¢w¢w¢w¢w, Understanding and Being: An Introduction and Companion to Insight,
edited by Elizabeth A. Morelli and Mark D.Morelli. (New York & Toronto :the
Edwin Mellen press , 1980.)
¢w¢w¢w¢w, Verbum: Word and Idea in Aquinas, Edited by D. Burrell.¡]Notre
Dame: University of Notre Dame Press, 1967.¡^
¤G¡B¬ÛÃö¤åÄm
Budernholzer, Frank E. "Science and Religion: Seeking a Common
Horizon", Zygon, vol. 19, no 3, Sept. 1984. pp. 351-368.
¢w¢w¢w¢w, 'What is Life-Current Scientific and Philosophical Perspectives'
International Conference on Cosmology: Religious and Scientific Perspectives,
Flanagan, Joseph, Quest for Self-Knowledge: An Essay in Lonergan's Philosophy,¡]Toronto:
University of Toronto Press, 1997.¡^
Menially, Hugo A. An Introduction to the Philosophy of Bernard Lonergan, ¡]Toronto:
University of Toronto Press, 1991.¡^
Muck, Otto, The Transcendental Method, ¡]New York: herder and herder, 1972.¡^
Oko, Dariusz, The Transcendental Way to God according to Bernard Lonergan,¡]Verlag
Peter Lang GmbH, Frankfurt am Main 1991¡^
Sala, Giovanni B., Lonergan and Kant: Five Essays on Human Knowledge, translated
by Joseph Spoerl. Edited by Robert M. Doran¡]Toronto: University of Toronto
press, 1994¡^
Tracy, David, The Achievement of Bernard Lonergan,¡]New York: herder and
herder, 1972.¡^
Kant, Immanual., Immanual Kant's Critique of Pure Reason. translated by Norman
Kemp Smith.¡]1965¡^
Kuhn, Thomas S., The Structure of Scientific Revolution, ¡]Chicago: University
of Chicago Press, 1970.¡^
Reichenbach, Hans The Rise of Scientific Philosophy ¡]University of California
Press, 1951¡^
Rorty, R. Philosophy and the Mirror of the Nature,¡]Princeton: Princeton
University press, 1979¡^
Schrodinger, Erwin. 1967 What Is Life? The Physical Aspect of the Living Cell
(with Mind and Matter and Autobiographical Sketches) Cambridge: Cambridge U.
Press.
¢w¢w¢w¢w,¡m¦¥§®Úªº»{ª¾²z½×¢w¢w¡m¬}¹î¡n¨÷¤@ÄÀ¸q¡n¡]¥x¥_¡Gõ¾Ç»P¤å¤Æ¤ë¥ZªÀ¡A1991¡^
* ¥»¤å´¿µoªí©ó2005¦~¥xÆWõ¾Ç¾Ç·|¦~·|º[¡uõ¾Ç¤Ï¬Ù»Pª¾Ãѳзs¡v¬ã°Q·|,2005¦~11¤ë20¤ê¡A¨Ã¸g»P·|¾ÇªÌ°Q½××q¦Ó¦¨¡A
µùÄÀ¡G
[1] ¦¥§®Úªº³Õ¤h½×¤å¬°¡m®¦Ãd»P¦Û¥Ñ¡nGrace and Freedom: Operative
Grace in the Thought of St. Thomas Aquinas, Ed. J. P. Burns.¡]London: Darton,
Longman & Todd; New York: Herder and Herder, 1971.¡^¡A¦b¬}¹î¤§«e³Ì«nªºµÛ§@¬°¡m¤ß»y¡nVerbum:
Word and Idea in Aquinas, Edited by D. Burrell.¡]Notre Dame: University of
Notre Dame Press, 1967.¡^¡A³o¤G³¡§@«~¬Ò¥H¦hº¿´µ¡]Thomas Aquinas¡^ªº«ä·Q¬°®Ö¤ß¡A¹î¨ä½×z¶i¸ô¥ç¬°¥Ñ§Î¦Ó¤W¾Ç¦Ó¤U¹F¡AµM¦b¨ä³Ì«ªº»Pì³Ð©ÊªºµÛ§@¡m¬}¹î¡n¤¤¡A«oª½¦Ü«á¥b³¡¤~²`¤J±´°Q§Î¤W¾Ç°ÝÃD¡A¥ç¤£¥i¤£¿×¬O¤@½Âà¡A¦b¡m¦s¦³»P²z¸Ñ¡nUnderstanding
and Being, edited by Elizabeth A. Morelli and Mark D.Morelli. (New York &
Toronto: the Edwin Mellen press , 1980.)¤¤¡A¦¥§®Ú¤]¬°¦¹°µ¤F¸ÑÄÀ¡A·§¨¥¤§¡A¥L»{¬°±q¨ãÅ骺¨Æ¨Ò¥Xµo§ó®e©ö«K¤HÅé»{»{ª¾¤§¬°¹ê¦b³o¤@¦^¨Æ¡C¨£«e´¦®ÑUnderstanding
and Being, p. 3.
[2] Brenard Lonergan, Insight: A Study of Human Understanding, ¡]London:
Longmans, Green & Co., 1957; London: Longman & Todd, reprinted, 1958.¡^p.
387.
[3] Tracy, David, The Achievement of Bernard Lonergan,¡]New York: herder and
herder, 1972¡^p. 98.
[4] Understanding and Being, p. 3-4.
[5] ¨ä¤j·N¬°ªü°ò¦Ì¼w¨ü©R¬°Áú¨Èù(Hiero)°ê¤ýų©w¤ý«a¡A¬Y¤Ñ·í¨ä¶i¤J¯D¬Ö¬~¾þ®É¡A¤ôº©·¸¨ì¬Ö¥~¡C³o®É¡A§x´bªºªü°ò¦Ì¼w¦b¯D¬Ö¤¤¬ðµMÆF¾÷¤@²{¡G¡u§â¤ý«a©ñ¨ì¤ô¤¤±}±}¡I¡vªü°ò¦Ì¼wÅåı¡A¦pªG¤ý«aºU¤FÅK½è¡A¦Ó¨ä«¶q«o»P¯Âª÷¤ý«a¬Û¦P¡A¥Ñ©óÅKªº±K«×¸û§C¡A¨äÅé¿n¶Õ¥²¤j©ó¯Âª÷©Ò»s¡AY±N¨ä¸m©ó¤ô¤¤¡A±Æ¥Xªº¤ô¶q¶Õ¥²¦h©ó¯Âª÷¤ý«a¡C¾Ú¦¹´N¥i¥H§PÂ_¬Ó«a¬O§_¦³°²¡C³oÓµo²{Åý¥L¿³¾Ä±o¸õ°_¨Ó¤j³Û¡GEureka¡I§Ú§ä¨ì¤F¡I«á¹Üªù¦Ó¥X¡C¨£Insight,
p. 3.
[6] ¬f©Ô¹Ïªº¹ï¸Ü¿ýMeno½g¤¤´y¼g¤F³o¼Ëªº¬G¨Æ¡GĬ®æ©Ô©³¹ïµÛ¤@Ó¤p¥£Áõ°Ý¡G¡u¦p¦ó±N¤@¥¿¤è§ÎÂX¤j¤@¿¡A¦Óºû«ù¥¿¤è§Î¡H¡v´N¦bĬ®æ©Ô©³µe¤F¤@¥|¤è§Î¨Ã¥Î¤F¤£¦Pªº¹Ï§Î»P·t¥Üªº³v¨B¤Þ¾É¤U¡A¤pªB¤Í²×©ó§ì¦ínÂI¡]point¡^¡A±o¨ì¬}¹î¡AÁöµM¦¥§®Ú»{¬°³o¬O¬f©Ô¹Ï¬O¬°¨ä¡u¦^¾Ð»¡¡v´M¨D²z¾Ú¡A«o¤£Ãª¬}¹î¤§¨Æ¹ê¡C¨£Understanding
and Being, pp. 21-2.
[7] Insight, pp. 3-4.
[8] Insight, p. 19.
[9] David Tracy, The Achievement of Bernard Lonergan, p. 107.
[10] David Tracy, op.,cit., p. 107.
[11] ¨£Alex RosenbergµÛ¡A¼Ú¶§±ÓĶ¡m·í¥N¬ì¾Çõ¾Ç¡n¡]Philosophy of
Science¡^¡]¥x¥_¡G³§B¤å¤Æ¡A2004¡^¶170-8.
[12] Insight, p. 279.
[13] Frederick E. Crowe, Lonergan.¡]Collegeville: Liturgical press, 1992.¡^p.
60.
[14] Lonergan, "Cognitional structure" see, Collection, Edited by
Frederick E. Crowe, ¡]New York: herder and herder, 1967.¡^p. 230.
[15] Joseph Flanagan, Quest for Self-Knowledge: An Essay in Lonergan's
Philosophy,¡]Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1997.¡^pp. 122-3
[16] Insight, p. 103.
[17] Understanding and Being, p. 3. ; 14. ; 15.; 21.; 33.
[18] Understanding and Being, p. 33.
[19] Joseph Flanagan, op. cit., p. 95.
[20] Understanding and Being, p. 64.
[21] Insight, pp. 531-2.
[22] Insight, p. 44.
[23] Insight, p. 37.
[24] Insight, p. 41.
[25] Insight, p. 41.
[26] ±q¬¥§J¤À¿ëªì©Ê-ª«ªº¥»µM¼ËºA¡A»P¦¸©Ê-ª«¬°§Ú·P©xªºÄ±¹î¶}©l¡Aª«ªº¡u¨â«©Ê¡vª§½×¡A¦b¤@¬q¾ú¥vªøªe¤¤¦ü¥G±q¥¼¶¡Â_¡A³oÓÃh¼w®üµ§¤Uªº¡u¥»©Ê¤§¨â¤À¡v¡]bifurcation
of nature¡^¡A¹ïª«ªº²z¸Ñ¬OÓ¤£©¯ªºµo®i¡A¦ýY¥H¦¥§®Ú¹ï¡uª«§Ú¬ÛÃö¡v»P¡uª«ª«¬ÛÃö¡vªº¤À¿ë«h¥i»´©ö©î¸Ñª§½×¡C
[27] Insight, p. 737.
[28] Joseph Flanagan, op. cit., p. 113.
[29] Lonergan, Method in Theology, ¡]New York: Herder and Herder, 1972.¡^pp.
81-3.
[30]
®Ú¾Ú¶êªº©w¸q¤U§¹¬üªº¶ê¨ä¹ê¤£¦s¦b¡A¦P¼Ëªºª«Åé¤U¼Y©w«ß¤§©Ò¥H¯à¦¨¥ß¬O¦bµ´¹ï¯uªÅ¤U¡A¦ýµ´¹ï¯uªÅ«o¥u¬O°²³]¡CUnderstanding
and Being, p. 61.
¥ç¥i°Ñ¬Ý³¯¤å²»¡A¡m¬}¹î»Pª¾ÃѪº¥i¯à©Ê¡G¦¥§®Ú»{ª¾²z½×¬ã¨s¡n»²¤¯¤j¾Çõ¾Ç¬ã¨s©Ò³Õ¤h½×¤å¡A¥Á94,
¶28-34.
[31] Insight, p. 47.
[32]
°ò¥»±¡ªpªº·N«ä¬°¨ä±¡ªpº¡¥þ¤F®Ú¥»ºc³y¤Wªº¬}¹î¤§©Ò»Ýªº±¡ªp¡A±Æ°£¤F©Ò¦³¥~¨Óªº¤zÂZ¡A«e¦]»P«áªG¦b¨CÓ±¦V¤W³£¯à¥Ñ¤@Óºc§@ªº¼Ò«¬©Ò½T¥ß¡C¸Ô¨£Insight,
p. 47.
[33] Ibid.
[34] Ibid.
[35] Ibid.
[36] ¦³Ãö¥j¨å«ßªº¨ãÅé½×Â_¥i¥H°Ñ¦ÒInsight, pp.46-7.¡F¦P®É¡A¥ç¥i°Ñ¦ÒÃö¥Ã¤¤±Ð±Âªº¸àÄÀ¡C°Ñ¨£¡m¦¥§®Úªº»{ª¾²z½×¢w¢w¡m¬}¹î¡n¨÷¤@ÄÀ¸q¡n¡]¥x¥_¡Gõ¾Ç»P¤å¤Æ¤ë¥ZªÀ¡A1991¡^¶69-74.
[37] Understanding and Being, p. 72.
[38] Erwin Schr?dinger, What Is Life? The Physical Aspect of the Living Cell:
Mind and Matter, (Cambridge: Cambridge U. Press. 1967) p. 89.
Á§¤B®æ¦P¼Ëµo²{¡]©Î§ó¦n»¡§ó¦µo²{¡^¥j¨å»P²Îpªº¾÷¨î¦s¦b¡A¦¹®Ñ¬°¤@«nªº¬ì´¶®Ñ¦Ó²`¨ã»ùÈ¡A¦¥§®Úªº¨£¸Ñ¦b¬ì¾Ç²Ó¸`¤è¦¡»P¨ä¬Ûªñ¡Aȱo°Ñ¦Ò¡C¦¹®Ñ¦³¤¤¤åª©¡A¨£¤³¸U·Ô¡B¥ªÄõªâĶ¡m¥Í©R¬O¤°»ò¡n¡]¥x¥_¡G¿ßÀYÆN®Ñ©Ð¡A1992¡^¡C¦¹³B©Ò¤Þ¤§¤å¥i¨£¤¤¤åª©¶117-124
[39] Eriwin Schrodinger, op. cit., p. 85.
[40] Insight, p. 103.
[41]
½Ñ¦p¬}¹î¨ì¹CÀ¸ªÌn¤£¬O§@¹ú¡An¤£´N¬O¦³¤@¡u¯«¯µ¡vªº¤O¶q¤¶¤Jµ¥µ¥¡C
[42] Hugo Meynell, An Introduction to the Philosophy of Bernard Lonergan, ¡]Toronto:
University of Toronto Press, 1991.¡^p. 23.
[43]
µJº¸¬O²Ä¤@¦ì¥Î¼Æ¾Çµ¥¦¡ªí¹F¤F¹q¯àÂà´«¦¨¼ö¯àªº¤ñ¨Òªº¬ì¾Ç®a¡C¥L½T¥ß¤F¦UºØ§Î¦¡ªº°Ê¯à°ò¥»¤W¨ã¦³¤@P©Ê¡C¥Lªº¤½¦¡¬°P=I2R¡A§Y¨C¬íªº¹q¥\²vPµ¥©ó¹qªýR¼¥H¹q¬yIªº¥¤è¡C
Copyright (c) Hong Kong Society of Humanistic Philosophy. All Rights Reserved.